Introducing audio.science

Mad_Economist

Administrator
Staff member
Industry
I suppose you're wondering why I've called you all here tonight. Particularly because this is a forum post, and you likely got here from a search engine or a social media post link. Welcome to the inaugural post of audio.science, a new platform for discussion, reviews, measurements, analysis, and everything else to do with the scientific side of audio. This forum is a joint project among a number of individuals united by a shared desire for a place to talk about audio science outside of the context of an inevitably-disappearing Reddit thread or closed-to-outsiders Discord channel. Whether your interest is in loudspeakers, headphones, recording, spatial audio, DIY projects, or simply bloody-minded number fetishism, we hope to make a home for it here.

Why a new audio science forum? It's a fair question — why should you go through another signup process, have another forum software emailing you thread updates, register your username here as well as all the other places? Well, at its core, because what we wanted didn't really exist: an internet-public community forum centered on the discussion of audio science, governed collaboratively rather than by any single voice, without any pre-established baggage, with a high standard of conduct. Somewhere that could exist as an equal meeting space for any sort of good faith technical discussion in the audio hobby between anyone, be they community figures, brand representatives, viewers like you, or even the owners of other audio fora.

This site is meant to build a community that includes everyone who is ready to participate respectfully and earnestly in discussing, debating, and digressing on the science of audio, and to apply those standards of discourse to everyone evenhandedly and universally. The admin team is already almost a dozen and will probably be expanding a bit, and while it's impossible to completely avoid bias, we fully intend to hold our co-moderators' posts to the same standards as any other poster. On the internet, tone can be unclear in posts and tempers can run hot, but this only worsens communications and community, and we'd like to build a space which is free of flames but completely open to respectfully articulated disagreement.

audio.science is a deliberately pretty austere design, and it's nobody's baby in particular, and it isn't changing in either respect. This forum's aspiration is to be a forum, because we need a forum, and it's going to stay that way. audio.science is not and likely will never be monetized in any form, does not accept sponsorship, and if donations are accepted, they will be limited to operating costs of the website. We're not planning to launch audio.science the Twitch channel, audio.science the convention, or audio.science the flamethrower. This isn't hostility to content creation or monetization — several of the admins here are involved in both — but rather a firewalling of the forum from things outside of its scope as a space for discussion. The only people in charge of audio.science are the collective admin team, operating as individuals, and while we welcome brands to participate so long as they do so constructively, there will never be any external influence on moderation policy by outside firms or groups.

In large part, this site exists because a very large amount of useful information about audio science is posted daily to discords, slacks, and reddit threads where it vanishes into the internet memory hole to never be seen again until it's referenced in a youtube video and people are left scratching their heads. Having a central archive for as much of what is known — and, ideally, as many of the caveats, disputes, and clarifications about it — for our community as possible is something we feel is important and it saves us having to link to our reddit posts. That doesn't mean there will be a centrally approved doctrine here — if anything, much the opposite: we want to make a space for the terminology, hypotheses, and data we're all discussing across half a dozen sites to be fully documented, discussed, demonstrated, disputed, and if necessary disproven.

This site and its founders are pretty deep in the weeds of the audio hobby, but we're aiming to make a space which is accessible for people who are just wondering what an HRTF is or why speakers aren't as simple as having a flat FR to be perfect too. A lot of the people who will be joining here will be jaded veterans, but we ask you all to meet questions that seem trivial to you with a charitable interpretation of people's knowledge of feldspars
1794595567056.webp

and earnest answers (even if they're just "here's a link to a thread where that's explained"). Audio as a community is pretty hard for people to get their heads around, and audio science doubly so, so we all have to actively pull against the tendency to just say "RTFM"...because, frankly, there isn't a fuckin' manual that anyone can be reasonably expected to have read for a lot of these questions. Please treat earnest, curious ignorance with charity, or else.

We're going to be pretty proactive in moderation for tone and civility here, and we ask that anyone joining help us in two ways: first, report posts you think are ill-intended, hostile, in bad faith, or otherwise not something you can see a productive result from engaging with — this will let us see where things may be getting heated. Second, please don't respond to those posts — it's tempting to flame someone who you think is posting in bad faith, but there's no good outcome: if it's a troll, you are feeding them. If it's someone who is just earnestly mistaken or who you are reading more harshly than they intend, it's a needless conflict, and in either case it clutters up our threads. That doesn't mean you can't disagree with people — the furthest thing from it, we expect this site to be a sea of "um, actually" — just that you have to do so politely and with a charitable reading of their statements.

As with any audio science community, the burden of proof looms over all conversations here, and we have to be explicit: the burden of proof is on the party making the claim. "I hear a difference between cable X and cable Y so cables make a difference in sound quality, prove me wrong" is not an argument that can be constructively engaged with. Neither, however, is "nobody can hear the difference between audio codecs", for example — if you make strong claims like that, please provide evidence, or at minimum be prepared to back them. In the process, we think that people will find that what the evidence strongly backs is often much less inflammatory to people who would otherwise disagree — "Listeners consistently rated the Harman target very highly in sound quality" is both a much more defensible claim than "Headphones which do not match the Harman target are defective" and one much less likely to start a fight.

If after reading all this you're still interested in posting, please review The Rules and make an account. Initial posts will be moderator approved to control for spamming, apologies for the inconvenience.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top